ACT360 Web & IT Inc.
Blog

Cloud Backup vs Local Backup: Which Is Safer for Your Business?

Local backups restore fast but share your building and your network. Cloud backups survive a fire but depend on your internet and your passwords. Here’s how each one fails, and how to combine them.

Administrator working on an office server, where a local backup usually lives before a cloud backup vs local backup decision

QUICK ANSWER

Quick answer

Neither cloud nor local backup is safer on its own. Local backups restore fastest but can be lost with the building or reached by ransomware on your network. Cloud backups survive a disaster at the office but restore at internet speed and depend on account security. The safest setup uses both, with one copy offline or immutable.

KEY TAKEAWAYS

What to remember

  • Local backup wins on restore speed; cloud backup wins on surviving fire, flood or theft at the office.
  • Both are exposed to ransomware if they can be reached from your network or deleted with a stolen password.
  • The Cyber Centre recommends two or more backups stored offline and inaccessible from your network.
  • Restoring 500 GB over 100 Mbps takes about 11 hours at best; the first upload at 10 Mbps takes about 4.6 days.
  • Your business stays responsible for data in a cloud backup, including where it's stored and who can delete it.
  • Test a restore from every copy and time it before you need it.
In this article
  1. What Is the Difference Between Cloud Backup and Local Backup?
  2. How Do Cloud and Local Backups Compare?
  3. Which Is Safer Against Ransomware?
  4. How Long Does It Take to Restore From Each?
  5. Who Is Responsible for Data in a Cloud Backup?
  6. How Do You Combine Cloud and Local Backup?
  7. Which Mix Fits Your Business?
  8. How Does ACT360 Approach Cloud and Local Backups?
  9. Final Thought

Local backups restore fast but share your building and your network. Cloud backups survive a fire but depend on your internet and your passwords. Here's how each one fails, and how to combine them.

TL;DR Neither is safer on its own. A local backup is the fastest way back from a dead server or a deleted folder, but it sits in the same building and often on the same network as the data it protects. A cloud backup survives fire, flood and theft, but it’s only as safe as the account that controls it and only as fast as your internet. The safest setup uses both, with at least one copy offline or locked against deletion.

Cloud backup and local backup protect against different disasters, so the question isn’t which one to pick. It’s which failures each one leaves you exposed to. This guide supports our business continuity and disaster recovery services and our cloud migration services, since the backup question usually comes up the moment a business starts moving off its own servers.

I’m Jeffrey Bowles, Partner and Director of IT Services at ACT360. If you want the full checklist for a backup plan, that’s in our data backup best practices guide. This one is the head-to-head: where each type wins, where it breaks, and how to put the two together.

What Is the Difference Between Cloud Backup and Local Backup?

A local backup is a copy of your data kept on site, on a backup appliance, a network storage device (NAS) or external drives. A cloud backup is a copy sent over the internet to a provider’s data centre, where it’s stored and managed off site.

Both are real backups as long as they keep earlier versions you can go back to. That’s the line between backup and sync. OneDrive, Dropbox or a mirrored drive copies changes instantly, including deletions and encrypted files, so a mistake or an attack spreads to every synced copy.

The Canadian Centre for Cyber Security’s tips for backing up your information recommend the 3-2-1 approach: three copies of your information, on two different media types, with one copy kept off site. Read that closely and you’ll notice it already assumes a mix. One type of storage isn’t enough, and neither is one location.

How Do Cloud and Local Backups Compare?

Here’s how the two compare on the things that decide whether you get your data back.

Factor Local backup Cloud backup
Restore speed Fast. Limited by your office network, not your internet Limited by your internet download speed, unless the provider can ship a drive
Fire, flood or theft at the office Lost along with the original if stored in the same place Survives, because the copy is somewhere else
Ransomware on your network Exposed if the device is connected and reachable Exposed if the backup can be deleted from your network or with a stolen password
Hardware failure Your hardware, your problem: drives age and fail Provider’s hardware; you pay for the service, not the disks
Cost pattern Upfront hardware, replaced every few years Monthly or annual fee, usually by the amount stored
First full backup Quick over the office network Can take days over a slow upload connection
Where the data lives Your premises The provider’s region: check it’s where you need it

Notice that the ransomware row reads the same for both. That’s not a typo. It’s the reason the type of storage matters less than whether at least one copy is out of reach.

Which Is Safer Against Ransomware?

Neither, by default. A connected local device and an online cloud backup can both be reached by an attacker who gets into your network or your admin account. The safe copy is the one that’s offline or locked so it can’t be changed or deleted.

The Cyber Centre’s ransomware playbook puts it plainly: many ransomware variants are designed to locate, spread to and delete your system backups, and backups stored online or in the cloud are the ones most commonly susceptible. It recommends two or more backups stored offline and inaccessible from your networks and internet connection. The backup tips add a local warning too: if you back up to a NAS on your network, ransomware can spread to the NAS and compromise your backups.

Statistics Canada’s survey on the impact of cybercrime found that about 1 in 6 (16%) Canadian businesses were affected by a cyber security incident in 2023, and 13% of those reported ransomware. Most ransomware victims (88%) didn’t pay. Not paying only works if there’s something clean to restore from.

There are two practical ways to get a copy out of reach:

  • Offline. Drives that are disconnected after each backup and stored securely, ideally off site. Simple, cheap, and dependent on someone doing it.
  • Immutable cloud storage. Microsoft describes immutable storage as keeping data in a write once, read many (WORM) state, where it can’t be modified or deleted for a set period. Azure Backup’s soft delete keeps deleted backup data for 14 days by default, extendable to 180, so a malicious deletion can be undone.
External SSD next to a computer, a simple local backup that can be disconnected and stored offline

How Long Does It Take to Restore From Each?

Restore time is where local backup wins. A cloud restore is limited by your internet download speed, so bringing back a whole server can take many hours, while a local copy comes back at office-network speed.

Some rough arithmetic, ignoring overhead (real transfers are slower):

Job (illustrative) Connection Best-case time
Restore 500 GB from the cloud 100 Mbps download About 11 hours
Restore 500 GB from the cloud 50 Mbps download About 22 hours
First full upload of 500 GB to the cloud 10 Mbps upload About 4.6 days
Restore one 2 GB folder from the cloud 50 Mbps download About 5 to 6 minutes

Upload speed matters more than people expect, because the first full cloud backup has to go up your connection. The CRTC’s universal service target is 50 Mbps down and 10 Mbps up. Its most recent coverage figures show 91.4% of Canadian households can get that, but only 62% in rural communities. A business outside town on a slow line should plan its first cloud backup carefully, and keep a local copy for fast restores.

The takeaway for planning: decide how long each system can be down, then check whether a cloud-only restore fits inside that window. If it doesn’t, you need a local copy too. Our guide to business continuity vs disaster recovery explains how recovery time targets fit into the bigger plan.

Who Is Responsible for Data in a Cloud Backup?

Moving backups to the cloud moves the hardware worry to the provider, not the responsibility. Your business still owns the data, decides where it’s stored, and controls the accounts that can delete it.

The Cyber Centre’s backup tips say that cloud storage can be beneficial and that many providers offer security features you might not have in-house, but that your organization is always legally responsible for protecting its data, and that you should consider data residency. Its guidance on adopting cloud services draws the line clearly: providers are responsible for security of the cloud, and your organization is accountable for securing what you put in it. Microsoft’s shared responsibility model says the same thing in fewer words: you own your data and identities.

For personal information, the Office of the Privacy Commissioner’s cross-border guidelines confirm you stay accountable for information a provider holds for you. So before signing up for a cloud backup service, ask three things: which country the backups are stored in, who at your company can delete them, and whether that deletion can be undone.

The account side is easy to overlook. Protect the backup console with its own admin account and MFA, separate from anyone’s everyday email login. Our MFA implementation guide covers the rollout.

How Do You Combine Cloud and Local Backup?

The safest setup combines a local copy for fast everyday restores, a cloud copy that survives a disaster at the office, and at least one copy that’s offline or immutable so ransomware and stolen passwords can’t reach it. Then you test restores from each. Here’s the order to set it up.

  1. List every system and where its data lives, including Microsoft 365 and laptops.
  2. Set how long each system can be down and how much data it can lose.
  3. Keep a local backup for anything that must be restored within hours, not a day.
  4. Send a second copy to a cloud backup service stored in the region you need.
  5. Make one copy offline or immutable, and confirm who can and can’t delete it.
  6. Give the backup system its own admin accounts with MFA and alerts on changes.
  7. Test a restore from each copy on a schedule and write down how long it took.

Step 7 is the one that tells you whether steps 1 to 6 worked. Our article on how often to test your backups gives a practical cadence.

Which Mix Fits Your Business?

Your situation Lean on Watch out for
Office with an on-site server running accounting or ERP Local copy for fast restores, plus cloud or offline off-site copy A NAS on the same network as the server
Fully on Microsoft 365, no servers left A separate cloud backup of Microsoft 365 Treating recycle bins and retention as a backup
Rural site on a slow internet connection Local copy first, cloud copy seeded carefully Days-long first upload and slow full restores
Clinic, law firm or business with personal information Cloud backup stored in Canada, plus an offline copy Backups held in another country without anyone checking
Several locations Cloud backup to one standard, local copies where restores must be fast Each site doing its own thing with no one checking

Whatever the mix, the Microsoft 365 point applies to almost everyone: recycle bins and retention settings help with recent mistakes, but they aren’t a backup. Our backup best practices guide explains the limits.

How Does ACT360 Approach Cloud and Local Backups?

We start with what each part of the business can live without, and for how long. That’s the Assess and Comprehend part of our ACTION approach. The mix of local, cloud and offline copies follows from those answers, along with where the backups are stored and who can touch them.

Local hardware ages, and that’s easy to forget when backups report success every night. A commercial painting contractor with roughly 35 staff across four locations came to us with a server whose drives were failing, holding its accounting and job data. The drives were replaced before any data was lost, and the replacement was sized as a bridge to a planned move of the accounting system off-premise. The case study covers the server decision. It doesn’t report backup restore times, so we won’t quote any.

We’re based in Barrie. Our pages on cloud migration in Barrie and business continuity in Barrie cover how this works for businesses across Simcoe County.

Final Thought

Ask a different question. Not “cloud or local?” but “if the building, the network or the admin password were lost tomorrow, which copy would still be there, and how long would it take to come back?” If you can answer that for each of the three, you’re in good shape.

If you can’t, our free IT Readiness Assessment is a 30-minute review of your backups, security and recovery plans, with a short list of what to fix first. You can also call 705-739-2281 or email [email protected].

FAQ

What Business Owners Ask About Cloud and Local Backups

Is a cloud backup enough on its own?

Usually not, because a cloud backup that can be deleted from your network or with a stolen admin password is exposed to the same ransomware as everything else. The Cyber Centre recommends two or more backups stored offline. A local copy also restores far faster than pulling everything back over the internet.

Our NAS backs up every night. Doesn't that count?

It counts as one copy, kept on site. If the NAS is connected to your network, the Cyber Centre warns ransomware can spread to it, and a fire or break-in takes it out with the server. Pair it with an off-site copy and one that’s offline or immutable.

How fast can we get our data back from a cloud backup?

About 11 hours at best for 500 GB over a 100 Mbps connection, before overhead, so a full server restore from the cloud is often an overnight job or longer.

Single files and folders come back in minutes. The slow part is restoring everything at once, which is exactly the situation after ransomware or a dead server. That’s why businesses with tight recovery targets keep a local copy too, and why it’s worth timing a real restore before you need one.

Are cloud backups stored in Canada?

Only if you choose a provider and region that stores them here. Ask where the backup copies sit, not just the live data, because PIPEDA keeps your business accountable for personal information wherever a provider holds it.

Cheaper option: cloud backup or a local backup device?

Local hardware costs more upfront and gets replaced every few years, while cloud backup is an ongoing fee that grows with the amount stored. Many businesses pay for both, because each covers failures the other can’t.

The cheaper question to ask is what a day without your systems costs, then size the backups to that.

Where should we start if we're not sure what we have?

Pick one important system and restore it from each backup you think you have, then time it. That single test tells you more than any report. For a fuller review, ACT360’s free 30-minute IT Readiness Assessment looks at your backups, security and recovery plans.

KEEP READING

Related Posts

Read Small Business Cybersecurity Checklist for Ontario: 12 Controls to Check This Quarter Office manager with a clipboard working through a small business cybersecurity checklist on her laptop

Small Business Cybersecurity Checklist for Ontario: 12 Controls to Check This Quarter

A practical cybersecurity checklist for Ontario businesses with 10 or more staff, built on the Canadian Centre for Cyber Security baseline: 12 controls, what done looks like, and what to fix first.

Read Phishing Awareness Training for Ontario Businesses: How to Run It So Staff Actually Report Staff in a conference room during a phishing awareness training session at an Ontario business

Phishing Awareness Training for Ontario Businesses: How to Run It So Staff Actually Report

How Ontario businesses with 10 or more staff can run phishing awareness training that changes behaviour: who to train first, what to cover, how simulations fit, and how to make reporting easy.